The Schoolhouse at Cannondale
was built just after the Civil War, in 1872 and has been owned and operated by Chef Tim LaBant, a native of Wilton, since 2006. The setting of this authentic one room schoolhouse along the banks of the rushing Norwalk River, makes for an unusual destination dining experience. The deep chocolate hue on the walls, the comfortably upholstered banquet seating that runs under the windows that frame the river just outside, the simple decor accented by 4-5 framed photos of classes of students and teachers from over 100 years ago, sets the tone.
This quintessential New England scene is authentic, inviting and superb.
Our first visit was for dinner the week before Christmas. We let the chef know, three days prior to our reservation, that
half of our party was vegetarian
. Although the menu clearly states that “substitutions are politely declined,” LaBant is happy to accommodate those with specific food restrictions if he knows about them 3-4 days in advance.
With a focus on sourcing as many ingredients as possible from local farms
, a commitment to using meats raised without the use of hormones or antibiotics, and an adherence to strict guidelines for sustainable fishing, discriminating diners have high expectations about the quality and inventiveness of the offerings at the Schoolhouse. We were not disappointed.
We began with a generous bowl of warming
. The velvety puree glistened with truffle oil and rewarded with deep earthy flavors. We enthusiastically shared
“Egg in the bread with arugula salad of pickled shimeji and preserved yuzu."
The poached egg was nestled neatly in a thick brioche bread cup and provided rich contrast to the sharp greens and pickled shimeji, Asian mushrooms with a pleasantly springy texture. The preserved yuzu is a tart Asian fruit which added another layer of mystery to the pleasingly tangy yet surprisingly rich combination of ingredients. This dish was served with bacon for the meat eaters in our party, and the rich cured pork was a perfect complement to its usual breakfast partner. Unafraid to ruin our appetites, we moved on to the
beet ravioli filled with salty feta and mache
, presented on a bold magenta puddle of beet puree and punctuated by bright green shelled pistachios. There were many contrasts on the plate:
gorgeous counterpoints of flavors and textures and bright colors to awaken the senses.
As we transitioned to the main courses, our selections divided us along the carnivore/vegetarian line.
We opted for the
chesnut agnolotti filled with Maitake mushrooms
enveloped in a parsnip, apple and brown butter emulsion. At first glance we spotted fish roe atop this delicate dish but realized this accent came from tiny pearls of tart apple...a clever ruse. Chef LaBant loves his exotic mushrooms and just when we thought we had eaten our fill of exquisite mushrooms in the soup, we were thrilled to detect mushrooms again, in these folded pockets of pasta. We shared a generous plate of
Bronzini with rich saffron risotto,
preserved tomatoes, fennel, and a generous mound of black trumpet mushrooms.
On the carnivorous side, the “
Flat Iron Steak
with celery root puree, trumpet mushrooms, and Brussels sprouts” arrived with a perfect uniform pink interior, a
sous-vide preparation resulting in the tenderest possible mouthfeel.
The velvety meat gave way to an intense beefy flavor, all heightened by the delicate sauce and highly textured mushrooms. Two of our favorite cuts of pork came paired in our next dish,
Berkshire pork loin and cured pork belly.
These were accented with creamy polenta and sweet baby beets, a rustically elegant and expertly cooked entree.
LaBant’s farm to table approach produced nuanced and complex flavors that thrilled each of us that eve.
He is wonderfully unselfconscious as exemplified in his friendly, highly trained servers and his offering a
selection of artisanal cheeses
as first course or dessert. We asked our knowledgeable server to present a selection for the table. He carefully described each cheese and its nutty or fruity jewel-like accompaniment in this well curated course.
Not wanting to miss out on the
, we ordered our dessert at the start of the meal. We had forgotten all about it when it was presented to us with a happy mound of
pink speckled candy cane ice cream
drizzled in dark chocolate sauce. The subtle crunch in the ice cream was an unexpected and delightful nod to the season. Our only regret was that we couldn't possibly make room to taste any of the other pastry chef’s desserts, which included
wildflower honey panna cotta with gingerbread spiced caramel corn, star anise honey and earl grey tea sorbet.
We won’t wait too long before returning to explore the rest of the dinner and dessert menu.
We did return a few weeks later for brunch
, on a bright but frigid day. The scene was even more magical in the daylight, as the snow capped rocks along the river’s edge poked through to remind us of the river’s presence. I am a big fan of
small and focused menus
. Fewer choices, on a Sunday morning, seems just right. We easily chose four of the five breakfast items to share with our group. For those ready for lunch, the choices were
with black pepper-truffle mayo, served with hand cut fries and a side salad or Bronzini with black trumpet mushrooms, brussels and polenta croutons.
Here is the scoop on the breakfast items: I would go back to The Schoolhouse this afternoon if I could, just for the
. The perfectly poached eggs were indeed fresh and local from Millstone Farm, just as I suspected as soon as the bright orange yolk made its appearance. It was layered on
Wave Hill's lightly toasted bread
with barely cooked spinach leaves and a hollandaise sauce worthy of a prize. I requested it without the bacon but it comes with, also, and based on our previous dining experience, the bacon is sure to be wonderful.
We also shared the
Frittata with cipolini onions and spinach, topped with a generous amount of duck confit
, which my Francophile friend declared was perfect and an unexpected treat. The frittata was moist and slightly sweet with a generous serving of caramelized onions. The table shared a large slice of
quiche with bacon, chives and goat cheese
which was light and creamy with a pleasant tang from the goat cheese. Served with fresh greens and crisp potato rosti on the side, it could have fed two. Our only disappointment was the
French toast brioche
, but disappointment may be too strong a word. After delighting to unexpected elements in each of the breakfast items, the French toast seemed well, a little basic. Still, a generous portion of purple blackberries and quality maple syrup are not a bad thing if you want to stick with something more basic. And dessert after brunch? Completely over the top but we couldn't resist. We shared a
warm, moist square of spiced bread pudding
topped with coffee ice cream as we lingered over more strong coffee served from individual French presses. AH, YES! One last taste of hot chocolate with homemade squares of marshmallows, a super rich, “stand your spoon up in it” ambrosia topped off a wonderful winter brunch in this cozy and exceptional spot along the river in Cannondale.
Note: A tree covered patio along the Norwalk River is open for lunch and dinner on Fridays and Saturdays beginning in May, weather permitting.
for more information
The SCHOOLHOUSE is located at 34 Cannon Road, Wilton